The role of transparency in procurement: Revealed versus concealed scoring rules in sealed bid A + B auctions

Quiroga, B., Morizt, B., Guide Jr., V.D.

forthcoming | Quiroga, B, Morizt, B., Guide Jr., V.D.

Journal of Operations Management

The role of transparency in procurement: Revealed versus concealed scoring rules in sealed bid A + B auctions

We investigate the impact of using a clear scoring rule in a sealed bid multi‐dimensional (A+B) procurement auction, as frequently used in government procurement. The central procurement agency in Chile (ChileCompra) asked for help to understand how concealing the scoring rule affected buyers. Using an experiment, we analyze the effect of transparently communicating the scoring rule on bidding outcomes by comparing the buyer’s surplus and supplier profits when buyers expressly communicate the weight they place on a nonmonetary (B) attribute, versus when this information is concealed from bidders. In addition, we compare outcomes where the scoring rule is made visible only after the offers are submitted. If the scoring rule is not disclosed, outcomes are poorer for buyers, and sellers see their profits increase.

Publicado en: Journal of Operations Management

Artículo: ISI , Estadísticas / Gestión Operacional